
Yesterday, Alan Milburn’s report about NEETS (young people not in education, employment or training), entitled From a Welfare State to a Working State, was published. I spent 10 years focused on delivering higher education programmes which very much did concern themselves with the what next question but am also quite a sceptic of the current government, so I felt both compelled to read the report and ready to be disappointed by what I found. I was expecting to find the blame for the current situation placed firmly on the “snowflake generation”. I didn’t.
Instead Milburn appears to have spoken to a lot of young people in producing both this report and the earlier interim diagnostic report and, as I have myself found throughout my career, been impressed by them. I found there was quite a lot in his reports to agree with.
First of all, the focus on the first rung on the career ladder is encouraging. As the report says:
Young people are not the same as older workers. The welfare system has treated them as though they are. They are not returning to something. They are trying to reach something for the first time.
Milburn concludes that a different system is required: “an active system which accords them new entitlements to propel them towards independence through earning or learning”.
Second, the expansion of apprenticeships, including degree apprenticeships, as a vehicle to reduce the risk to employers of taking on young workers who need significant training.
Third, the simplification of all the current entry routes into different types of work into a single Youth Opportunity Service is welcome, allowing a UCAS-style single front door to employment opportunities.
Fourth, it is a cross-government project, requiring coordination between the Department of Work and Pensions, the Department of Health and Social Care and the Department of Education. All three will need to drive through significant reforms for the project to work. The Prime Minister has put his weight behind it, suggesting that the funding will be found.
And, on that, this feels like the first example of how the preventative departmental expenditure limit or PDEL, sitting alongside the more familiar investment and resource spending limits and first set out in the Budget last month, might operate at scale. This is spending which reduces future costs, in this case benefit payments to young people who have been helped into employment via the measures set out here. This report is full of PDEL:
As upfront investment in enhanced opportunity and support takes effect, savings will start to come from reduced spending on benefits while increased revenues for the public purse will flow from more people being in work and paying their taxes. The positive fiscal impact increases with sustained growth in young people’s participation rates until the package achieves fiscal savings in 2036/37.
This is telling a different story from the fiscal space nonsense previously spouted by the OBR.
But more than anything, at a time when every headline seems to be a new restriction on the young, restricting their access to everything from cigarettes to the internet to relationships with older men to social media to their own mobile phones, these are measures aimed at giving young people more opportunities and access. Some of the statistics are striking:
In 2023/24 ICBs [integrated care boards] spent just 1.04 per cent of their total spend on young people’s mental health. On average they spent 13 times more on adult than on young people’s mental health services.
One of the key aims of the reforms are to:
…move the needle on the ratio spent on young people between income replacement and employment support. At present for every £25 we spend on benefits we only spend £1 on support. As a result of these changes, within the next 10 years that ratio should be £2 to £1.
Now for the scepticism.
A role for mayors appears to have been inserted into nearly everything, which I expect to trigger unnecessary turf wars, at least at the outset. The way the previous Thrive into Work programme was shut down may mean some trust issues amongst the people the government would be hoping to recruit to their new scheme. The wait period for the Jobs Guarantee of 12 months (down from 18 months) is still too long. A lot hinges on digital mental health services being scaled up and accessed successfully by the young to free up community resource elsewhere. It is unclear how employers are going to be encouraged to keep on young workers after their 6 month subsidised period of employment ends. A sense of national mission will be required which I am not sure is there at the moment. And, in view of the need for long term funding and commitment to effect change here, will the PDEL be as protected from budgetary pressures as advertised? The FT regards it as “contentious” and other critics are considerably more trenchant. Some of the wider points about how to support young people to develop fulfilling careers in an employment landscape increasingly dominated by ways of avoiding training them, which I have been writing about for much of this year, remain largely unaddressed.
The biggest danger highlighted by the critics is that, without doing enough to boost the economy we are sending these young people into, we are risking creating, at great expense, a lot of temporary low quality jobs which do not give young people anything meaningful to build on. As Roy Lilley says:
The NHS is being pressured to sack experienced staff and will now be pressured to employ novices.
Yesterday, our biggest defence supplier BAE Systems announced it’s making 1,000 people redundant… what price an apprenticeship with them, now?
The employer experiences the totality of policy.
The suspicion must be, particularly as he appears to be making this a central plank of his government, that the Prime Minister has a primarily political objective here. The next United Kingdom general election is scheduled to be held no later than 15 August 2029.
Look at the proposed timeline for the roll out of the policy:
2027/2028
The first major delivery changes should come into operation in 2027/2028. During this period every area should develop a Participation Plan and the central YOS function should be mobilised. Existing employment, careers and youth services can then be brought together, with the new data infrastructure developed that enables the early identification of hidden NEETs and those at risk of becoming so. The roll out of Early Support Hubs is already in progress across England. This should be accelerated, and it is critical that there is also a rapid expansion of wider mental health and community-based support during this time. This will be complemented by the development of the digital offer, so that these services are available to young people as soon as possible.
In 2028, all established MSAs should have Participation Agreements in place and delivering a YOS model that both meets the national standards and the needs of their local area. For young people, this will mean they have a more joined-up experience of support across different services. Where areas haven’t stood up a YOS, there should be structured interim programmes that deliver similar services. As areas begin to establish their full suite of support, all young people living there should be increasingly supported by the YOS. It is likely that some places will be able to achieve full system integration much more quickly than others – the learnings from these leading authorities should be shared and used to refine wider implementation. In terms of opportunity creation, these first years should be about taking the immediate steps to stimulate demand by significantly expanding the Youth Jobs Grant, the Jobs Guarantee, supported internships, and clarifying legislation around youth hiring. The funding, capacity and infrastructure to radically increase further education, deliver a new pre-apprenticeship pathway, and incentivise employers to take on more apprentices will also need to be built during this period. In education settings, the focus should be on preventing disengagement and improving transition points. Improved data, key stage 3 checks and more flexible curriculum time should enable schools to identify difficulties sooner and provide targeted support before young people fall out of education. Strategic authorities should map and publish local routes from education into work and study both for the benefit of young people, and to understand where there are gaps. These reforms should reduce the risk of young people being left without a route when a course ends or breaks down, resulting in smoother transitions.
2029 onwards
By the end of 2029, every area should have a YOS or equivalent offer in place. Health should be fully integrated into regional governance. The Opportunity offer, Support offer and Health & Disability Fund offers should be guaranteed for any young person that needs them. This means that local health, employment, skills and welfare support must be all under a common plan and be able to deliver in a timely way and at the capacity and quality to meet demand. Once an area has sufficiently established their YOS and connected support, all new claims for benefits for 18 to 24 year-olds will be to Youth Allowance, Additional Costs Allowance and the Severe and Complex Needs Insurance in that area. Those on legacy benefits (UC, UC Health, PIP) will be assessed in the new youth benefit system at their scheduled reassessment date following a 6 month preparation period with the YOS where they can take up the new support and opportunity offers and prepare for the transition from old system to new.
There is the possibility of some sweet spot in this policy’s development where a large number of young people are in jobs, the money is still there and the targets for what should have happened by the end of 2029 have not yet been tested. That is when I imagine the election will be called.
And then? Well of course all kinds of things might happen over the next 10 years, and probably will. To return to Lilley:
His wider programme runs towards 2036, potentially across three parliaments, AI, redundancy, wars, techno-hacks and goodness knows what.
And, as he points out:
HMG has to find the bandwidth to…
- Cut the waiting lists.
- Increase defence spending.
- Build homes.
- Reform social care.
- Tee-up the EU for round-two.
- Improve productivity.
- Re-dis-organise the NHS, and…
… add a ten-year reconstruction of how government helps young people into work.
It ain’t gonna happen.
What would my advice be for young people entering this newly-tinkered-with jobs market? Much as before. Remember what a reverse-centaur is? (Cory Doctorow defines a reverse-centaur as “a machine that is assisted by a human being, who is expected to work at the machine’s pace”).
The risks of becoming a reverse-centaur have not been reduced at all. Indeed they may be increased if Amazon responds to the subsidies on offer at the scale I think they might: plenty of reverse-centaur jobs available in their vans and fulfillment centres. This would be regarded as a success by the government.
So how to avoid this outcome? As I suggested previously, the questions to ask at interview to identify whether the role is irretrievably reverse-centauresque would be of the following sort (and both the increase in the supply of roles and the need for employers to attract under 25s to claim the subsidy does shift the balance of power ever so slightly in your direction at interview stage):
- How big a team would I be working in? (This might not identify a reverse-centaur role on its own: you might be one of a bank of reverse-centaurs all working in parallel and identified “as a team” while in reality having little interaction with each other).
- What would a typical day be in the role? This should smoke it out unless the smokescreen they put up obscures it. If you don’t understand the first answer, follow up to get specifics.
- Who would I report to? Get to meet them if possible. Establish whether they are technical expert in the field you will be working in. If they aren’t, that means you are!
- Speak to someone who has previously held the role if possible. Although bear in mind that, if it is a true reverse-centaur role and their progress to an actual centaur role is contingent on you taking this one, they may not be completely forthcoming about all of the details.
To which I would now add a 5th:
5. What are your plans for when the government subsidy runs out?
We’d all like to hear the answer to that one.


































